Tyer was a seven-time All-American. Tyer was the 1993 ITA Senior of the Year and 1990 NCAA Rookie of the Year runner-up. Tyer won the NCAA Consolation Finals in singles as a sophomore. The four-time all-conference selection won was a three-time ITA South Region doubles champion. She currently holds the school’s career singles (106) and overall career wins (192) records. Led Sewanee to a national top-15 ranking all four seasons, including top-six finishes in 1990 and 1993. Off the court, she was a 1993 ITA/Graduate Scholar.